The popular vote canard

| What do you think? (2)
Category :

There's a slow-motion scam being perpetuated by the Clinton campaign and I must speak out.

The short version: Barring a complete Obama meltdown, you know, I know, and the American people know they can't win on elected delegates. So you're increasingly hearing them talk about the popular vote. If Hillary wins the popular vote, they argue, she should be our candidate. And that sounds like a pretty reasonable position. We all went through Florida in 2000. Electoral College? What a crock! Democracy is about one person one vote. If she wins the popular vote, little d democrats should insist she be the nominee, right?

The problem with that canard is that while you can argue "one person, one vote, electoral college, grrr" in the general, the nomination process is different. As we all know way too well, some states caucus, some states run primaries. As we also know, caucusing, like 'em or not, take a much bigger time commitment than pulling the lever in a primary, so the turnout numbers are dramatically depressed.

If the caucus states all have substantially lower vote turnout percentages than their primary bretheren, selecting a nominee by counting the total votes makes votes in a primary state worth a lot more than votes in a caucus state. How do fix that problem with the math? We find a neutral measure that assigns a total # of votes to each state based on their relative size. And yeah, we call those neutral measures "delegates." That's why, in the nomination process, delegates are a much truer measure of "popularity" than the popular vote.

I know the popular vote is popular. We should invite it to parties. We should buy it drinks. We should ask it to sign our yearbooks. We just shouldn't use it to choose our nominee.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://cecilvortex.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/3964

2 Replies | Add a Reply

 
  • Part of the problem is the method the Democratic party uses to determine a nominee. Hopefully this year's situation will lead to changes in the future that will help the party. In the meantime, the whole sour grapes routine is very tiring (and divisive IMHO).

  • no, no, no. only poplar votes count. everyone knows that votes by this rapidly growing, salicaceous tree of the genus Populus represent the true candidate. true i say.

    i will not stand idly by and allow poplars to be disenfranchised. not again, not this time. the days and nights of the white pine, that large, irregularly branched pine, or Pinus strobus, are over. over!!

Leave a comment

Subscribe

 About-Creativity.com
 CecilVortex.com

About-Creativity is a series of interviews with artists about their creative process.
Cecil Vortex has those interviews along with my own writing and tunes plus the occasional group-read of a challenging tome.

Archives

Good Stuff



The Bands-I've-Seen Project

Air
Baez, Joan
Bauhaus
Beach Boys, The
Bears, The
Beastie Boys, The
Beat Rodeo
Beck
Beirut
Belew, Adrian
Belly
Berlin
Beulah
Big Star
Billy Nayer Show, The
Black Flag
Black Uhuru
Black, Frank
Bottle Rockets
Bowie, David
Bragg, Billy
Brannigan, Laura
Breeders, The
Burrell, Kenny
Butthole Surfers
Buzzcocks
Camper Van Beethoven
Cake
Chilton, Alex
Cleary, Jon
Clinton, George
Costello, Elvis
Coulton, Jonathan
Court and Spark, The
Cracker
Dead Kennedys, The
Dead Milkmen, The
Decemberists, The
Dickies, The
DiFranco, Ani
Doe, John
Dr. John
Eskimo
fIREHOSE
Flaming Lips, The
Fountains of Wayne
Franti, Michael (with Charlie Hunter)
Funky Meters, The
Gabriel, Peter
George, Inara
Gone
Grass Roots, The
Grateful Dead, The
Grizzly Bear
Guthrie, Arlo
Harding, John Wesley
Heat, Reverend Horton
Heron, Gil Scott
Hitchcock, Robyn
Husker Du
Iguanas, The
Jarreau, Al
JayHawks, The
Jazz Butcher, The
Kelly Jones
Living Colour
Lobos, Los
Lovett, Lyle
Marsalis, Wynton
Marley, Ziggy
Mike Viola
Minus Five, The
Morphine
Movie Stars, The
negativland
Newsom, Joanna
Old 97s, The
Oranger
Osborne, Anders
Overwhelming Colorfast
Pavement
Pee
Pere Ubu
Pixies, The
Plays Monk
Polyphonic Spree
Prince
Ramones, The
Redman, Joshua
Reed, Lou
Replacements, The
Residents, The
Richman, Jonathan
Rollins, Sonny
Roy Hargrove
Seagal, Jonathan
Seeger, Pete
Semisonic
Shocked, Michele
Shriekback
Silver Spun Pickups
Sioux, Siouxsie
Sippy Cups, The
Sisters of Mercy, The
Snappin’ Box, A
Squeeze
Stone Temple Pilots
Sugar
Sutton, Tierney
Television
They Might Be Giants
Thinking Fellers Local Union 282
Throwing Muses
Trip Shakespeare
Tyner, McCoy
Uncalled For, The
Uncle Tupelo
Vega, Suzanne
Violent Femmes
Voice Farm
Wailers, The
Wainwright, Loudin III
Waits, Tom
Wilco
Wolfgang Press, The
X
Yellow Man
Yo La Tengo
Young, Neil
Zircus

Twitter

    T R B p o t d

    I run a lil' mailing list featuring short poems by a variety of fantastic poets. For example: Richard Brautigan. To join or learn more, just drop me a line.

    Legaleso

    Various and sundry, copyright Cecil Vortex.